Category Archives: withholding of removal

CA7 denies withholding to Mexican national as “particular social group” must be linked by something more than persecution

The BIA did not err by finding that an alien failed to identify a valid particular social group within the meaning of the statutes authorizing asylum and withholding of removal; The IJ and the BIA did not err by rejecting … Continue reading

Posted in 7th Circuit, 7th Circuit Cases- Aliens, Asylum, particular social group, withholding of removal | Leave a comment

CA7 Remands Withholding Claim to BIA for HIV Positive Gay Man from Mexico

Camarena, a Mexican citizen, was admitted to the U.S. for permanent residence in 1977, at age 10. He did not become a citizen. After a felony conviction for indecent solicitation of a minor, his permanent-residence status was revoked, and he … Continue reading

Posted in 7th Circuit, 7th Circuit Cases- Aliens, CA7 Remands Withholding Claim to BIA for HIV Positive Gay Man from Mexico, HIV Positive Gay Man from Mexico, withholding of removal | Leave a comment

Jabr v. Holder, Past Persecution, 7th Circuit

For more than two years, members of the Palestinian Islamic Jihad (PIJ), an organization that violently opposes the existence of Israel, tried to recruit Jabr to join their group. Jabr resisted because he is a member of Fatah, a political … Continue reading

Posted in 7th Circuit, 7th Circuit Cases- Aliens, Asylum, Convention Against Torture, material evidence, Palestinian Islamic Jihad (PIJ), past persecution, political asylum, withholding of removal | Leave a comment

Political Asylum, Pakistan, membership in the PML-N, Seventh Circuit

“Mustafa’s attackers were motivated in part by an anti-PML-N political opinion they attributed to him. Mustafa is therefore entitled to a presumption in favor of granting asylum. On remand, the government will have the opportunity to rebut that presumption by … Continue reading

Posted in Asylum, Pakistani Muslim League, political asylum, political opinion, withholding of removal | Leave a comment