November 6, 2012 General Election:
The Association’s Judicial Evaluation Committee (JEC) invites you to view its evaluations of judges running for retention and judicial candidates seeking election to vacancies on the Illinois Supreme Court, the Illinois Appellate Court and the Circuit Court of Cook County in the upcoming General Election to be held Tuesday, November 6, 2012.
- View the complete findings in the Green Guide to Judicial Candidates.
- View a two-page, printable Pocket Guide (take this quick guide with you to vote.
- Get the Pocket Guide on your smart phone at http://m.chicagobar.org/
Paid for by The Chicago Bar Association Judicial Evaluation Fund. A copy of The CBA Report is available from the State Board of Elections.
________________________________________
Pocket Guide
THE CHICAGO BAR ASSOCIATION
JUDICIAL RETENTION CANDIDATES
ELECTION DAY, TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 6, 2012
To be retained, a sitting judge must receive a 60% YES vote from those voting on the question: “Shall Judge ____ be retained?” You may vote for any or all of the judges listed in this section of the ballot. No judge is running against any other judge. The sole question is whether each judge should remain in his or her present office.
PUNCH # CANDIDATE FINDING
PUNCH # CANDIDATE FINDING
ILLINOIS APPELLATE COURT
201 James Fitzgerald Smith Yes
CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY
203 Carole Kamin Bellows Yes
205 Kathy M. Flanagan Yes
207 Moshe Jacobius Yes
209 Stuart F. Lubin Yes
211 Marvin P. Luckman Yes
213 Raymond Funderburk Yes
215 Stuart E. Palmer* Yes
217 Martin S. Agran Yes
219 Patricia Banks Yes
221 Ronald F. Bartkowicz Yes
223 Robert Lopez Cepero Yes
225 Garritt E. Howard Yes
227 Joseph G. Kazmierski, Jr. Yes
229 E. Kenneth Wright, Jr. Yes
232 Cynthia Brim NO
234 Rodney Hughes Brooks NO
235 Maureen Elizabeth Connors* Yes
237 Christopher Donnelly Yes
240 James D. Egan NO
241 Catherine Marie Haberkorn Yes
244 Lisa Ruble Murphy NO
245 Marya Nega Yes
247 Lee Preston Yes
249 Drella C. Savage Yes
251 James M. Varga Yes
253 Richard F. Walsh Yes
255 Camille E. Willis Yes
257 Marcia Maras Yes
259 Peter Flynn Yes
261 Paul A. Karkula Yes
263 P. Scott Neville, Jr.* Yes
265 Maura Slattery Boyle Yes
267 Mary Margaret Brosnahan Yes
269 Matthew E. Coghlan Yes
272 Loretta Eadie-Daniels NO
273 Joyce Marie Murphy Gorman Yes
275 Joan Margaret O’Brien Yes
277 Thomas David Roti Yes
279 Colleen F. Sheehan Yes
282 Pamela E. Hill-Veal NO
283 Orville E. Hambright Yes
285 Michael J. Howlett, Jr. Yes
287 Carl Anthony Walker Yes
289 Daniel Patrick Brennan Yes
292 Gloria Chevere NO
293 Grace G. Dickler Yes
295 Ellen L. Flannigan Yes
297 Carol M. Howard Yes
299 Jill C. Marisie Yes
301 James Michael McGing Yes
303 Mike McHale Yes 305 James Patrick Murphy Yes
307 Thomas W. Murphy Yes
309 Patrick W. “Pat” O’Brien Yes
311 Ramon Ocasio III Yes
313 Mary Colleen Roberts Yes
315 Diane M. Shelley Yes
VOTE NO FOR NOT RECOMMENDED CANDIDATES
232 Cynthia Brim NO
234 Rodney Hughes Brooks NO
240 James D. Egan NO
244 Lisa Ruble Murphy NO
272 Loretta Eadie-Daniels NO
282 Pamela E. Hill-Veal NO
292 Gloria Chevere NO
* Assigned to Appellate Court
THE CHICAGO BAR ASSOCIATION VOTE SMART GUIDE
ELECTION DAY, TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 6, 2012
COUNTY-WIDE JUDICIAL RACES
HQ – HIGHLY QUALIFIED Q-QUALIFIED NR-NOT RECOMMENDED
PUNCH # CANDIDATE FINDING
PUNCH # CANDIDATE FINDING
ILLINOIS SUPREME COURT
(Fitzgerald)
71 Mary Jane Theis (D) HQ
72 James Gerard Riley (R) Q
COOK COUNTY SUBCIRCUITS
(Subcircuit 2 – Stuttley)
91 Carl B. Boyd (D) NR
(Subcircuit 3 – McGann)
91 Maureen Leahy Delehanty (D) Q
(Subcircuit 3 – Moore)
92 Daniel R. Degnan (D) NR
(Subcircuit 4 – Riley)
91 Terry Gallagher (D) Q
92 Harry J. Fournier (R) NR
(Subcircuit 4A)
93 Edward M. Maloney (D) Q
94 Christine Cook (R) Q
(Subcircuit 6 – Delgado)
91 Beatriz Santiago (D) NR
(Subcircuit 7 – Jones)
91 Aicha Marie MacCarthy (D) NR
(Subcircuit 7 – Starks)
92 Tommy Brewer (D) Q
(Subcircuit 7 – Terrell)
93 William G. Gamboney (D) HQ
(Subcircuit 7 – Toney)
94 Kimberly D. Lewis (D) NR
(Subcircuit 8 – Chiola)
91 Celia Louise Gamrath (D) HQ
(Subcircuit 8 – Cole)
92 John H. Ehrlich (D) HQ
(Subcircuit 8 – Roy)
93 Deborah Jean Gubin (D) Q
(Subcircuit 8A)
94 Laura Liu (D) Q
(Subcircuit 9 – Bender)
91 Lionel Jean-Baptiste (D) Q
(Subcircuit 9 – Epstein)
92 Larry G. Axelrood (D) HQ
(Subcircuit 10 – Locallo)
91 Thomas R. Allen (D) Q
(Subcircuit 11 – O’Brien)
91 Michael R. Clancy (D) Q
(Subcircuit 11 – Urso)
92 Lisa Ann Marino (D) Q
(Subcircuit 12 – Rochford)
91 Andrea M. Schleifer (D) Q
92 James Paul Pieczonka (R) NR
(Subcircuit 13 – Pietrucha)
91 Paul S. Pavlus (R) Q
(Subcircuit 13A)
92 Martin C. Kelley (R) NR
(Subcircuit 14 – O’Gara)
91 Regina Ann Scannicchio (D) Q
ILLINOIS APPELLATE COURT
(Cahill)
73 Mathias William Delort (D) HQ
(Coleman)
74 Nathaniel Roosevelt Howse, Jr. (D) HQ
(Gallagher)
75 P. Scott Neville, Jr. (D) Q
(O’Brien)
76 Jesse G. Reyes (D) Q
(Theis)
77 Maureen Elizabeth Connors (D) Q
(Tully)
78 Terrence J. Lavin (D) Q
CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY
(Conlon)
79 Karen Lynn O’Malley (D) Q
(Jordan)
80 Jean Prendergast Rooney (D) HQ
(Kinnaird)
81 Erica L. Reddick (D) Q
(Moran)
82 Russell W. Hartigan (D) HQ
(O’Brien, Jr.)
83 Cynthia Ramirez (D) Q
(Frossard)
84 Diann Karen Marsalek (D) Q
(Pucinski)
85 Lorna Ellen Propes (D) HQ
(Simmons, Jr.)
86 Jessica A. O’Brien (D) Q
(Stewart)
87 Pamela M. Leeming (D) Q
(Stralka)
88 Michael Tully Mullen (D) HQ
(Ward)
89 Elizabeth Mary Hayes (D) NR
ATTENTION SUBCIRCUIT VOTERS:
Not recommended candidates in county-wide races
89 Elizabeth Mary Hayes (D) NR 91 Carl B. Boyd (D) NR
92 Daniel R. Degnan (D) NR
92 Harry J. Fournier (R) NR
91 Beatriz Santiago (D) NR
91 Aicha Marie MacCarthy (D) NR
94 Kimberly D. Lewis (D) NR
92 James Paul Pieczonka (R) NR
92 Martin C. Kelley (R) NR
Paid for by The Chicago Bar Association 2012 Judicial Evaluation Fund
Copy of The CBA Report is available from the State Board of Elections.
________________________________________
GREEN GUIDE
To Judicial Candidates in Cook County
The Chicago Bar Association’s Evaluations Of Judicial Candidates Running for Office In the November 6, 2012 General Election
Provided as a public service of The Chicago Bar Association
Produced by The Chicago Bar Association Office of Public Affairs, 321 South Plymouth Court, Chicago, Illinois 60604 (312) 554-2000.
By Board resolution, the Judicial Evaluation Committee (JEC) is the semi-autonomous committee of The Chicago Bar Association (CBA) that conducts evaluations of candidates for judicial offices and sitting judges seeking retention within Cook County. As a service to the public, The CBA reports the findings of the JEC for all elections. The evaluations are designed to inform the public and the courts of the qualifications, independence and integrity of judicial candidates. The CBA believes that the quality of the administration of justice in our courts is determined in large part by the quality of our judges.
History
The CBA has a long history of judicial evaluation, dating before the turn-of-the-century, and taking many forms over the years — from running a “Bar Ticket” in 1887 — to the present comprehensive procedure adopted in 1976. At that time, a special committee of the Board of Managers, chaired by then CBA President John D. Hayes, recommended a total revamping of the process to minimize political and bar politics, and embrace the concepts of random selection of evaluators and investigators, and to assure the confidentiality of the process and sources.
The CBA Board of Managers regularly reviews and evaluates the procedures and operations of the JEC. The JEC’s governing resolution and its guidelines were both revised in 1987. The current JEC governing resolution was amended on December 16, 2010.
Scope & Purpose
Judicial candidates and sitting judges who participate in The CBA’s screening process are evaluated on the basis of eight criteria: integrity, legal knowledge, legal ability, professional experience, judicial temperament, diligence, punctuality and health factors.
By providing these findings, along with “The Statements of Reasons,” The CBA helps inform and educate the public about the upcoming judicial contests in the general election.
The CBA’s 200-member Judicial Evaluation Committee annually invests thousands of volunteer attorney hours in this thorough, comprehensive and diverse peer review process evaluating more than 300 candidates for appointive and elective judicial positions within Cook County. The evaluation process for the primary candidates began in August 2011. The guidelines and standards developed by the 20,000-member CBA for rating judges have been adopted almost entirely by the American Bar Association as a model for local and state bar evaluation programs.
The Investigative Process
The Committee’s work begins when the candidate submits his or her completed questionnaire. The 16-page questionnaire for sitting judges, requires the candidate to list personal, professional and judicial references and to provide the names of lawyers who have recently appeared before him or her. Candidates with fewer than four years on the bench are also asked to identify adversaries with whom they worked before taking the bench. Lawyer candidates are asked to provide detailed information about their jury and non-jury trial experiences, the names of five judges before whom they have appeared and a list of at least 20 lawyers who have represented adverse positions in matters handled by them.
All candidates are also asked to relate any present or recent health problems and to submit written authorizations signed by their doctors. Complaints against a candidate to the Attorney’s Registration and Disciplinary Commission and the Judicial Inquiry Board are to be described, and relevant reports and correspondence submitted with the questionnaire. Criticism of professional misconduct, in any formal civil or criminal proceeding or in the media, must also be reported by the candidate.
The JEC obtained written materials dealing with the candidates’ judicial performance from the major newspapers. In several cases, transcripts and other relevant, publicly available documents relating to official investigations of judges and court personnel were obtained from official sources.
The complete file was then assigned to a two-person investigation team. The investigators conducted personal interviews with the listed legal references. A specially assigned team of investigators reviewed the files of the Attorney Registration and Disciplinary Commission and submitted to the investigators and the hearing panel a report on the information disclosed in those files. On completion of the interviews and a review of the file materials, the investigations team completed a comprehensive report regarding the qualifications of the candidate.
The Hearing Process
Hearings were conducted on Tuesday and Thursday evenings and on Saturday mornings. Hearing division members were randomly assigned, in accordance with the JEC resolution, to either of two hearing rooms by a blind drawing for room assignment. Typically, 12 to 15 JEC members were assigned to each room. Only at that time did they learn which candidates they would be evaluating and who the other members of the panel were. Each member of the hearing panel was provided with a copy of the investigator’s report, a copy of the completed questionnaire with all material submitted by the candidate, and copies of any other relevant documents including, in some cases, newspaper clippings and transcripts of court proceedings.
Each member and the candidate execute a written oath to keep the nature and content of the report, questioning, and hearing confidential.
The JEC included in its investigation all possible sources of information available to it. However, because the Committee cannot compel the production of evidence or the attendance of witnesses before it nor, understandably, expect disclosure by the authorities of evidence discovered in pending investigations, the JEC cannot be assured that it has uncovered all the evidence which, in the future, may lead to formal charges. Within its authority, the JEC develops the most complete record available and gives careful and thoughtful consideration to the available evidence.
A member of the Executive Committee chaired each hearing. The candidate was advised of the procedures to be employed at the hearing and then questioned at length by the chair in regard to abilities, experiences, perceived strengths and weaknesses and, where appropriate, specific problems disclosed in the investigation. The chair then invited questions from members of the hearing panel. The candidate was then given an opportunity to make any statement he or she chose in his or her own behalf. On excusing the candidate from the hearing room, the chair then opened the floor to discussion of the candidate’s qualifications among the panel members. Only after the members had been given the opportunity to openly voice their opinions was the issue of the finding of the JEC put to a vote.
The Vote
The hearing panel members voted by secret ballot and were asked to rate the candidate as “Highly Qualified,” “Qualified” or “Not Recommended.” A vote of 80 percent is required for a candidate to receive a “Highly Qualified” finding. A vote of 60 percent is required for a candidate to receive a “Qualified” finding. The failure of a candidate to receive 60 percent affirmative vote results in a finding of “Not Recommended.” Each hearing panel member was also asked for written comments on the candidate’s qualifications, areas worthy of commendation and areas of needed improvement. Following a tabulation of the vote, the chair reviewed and capsulized the written comments in preparing the statement of reasons given in support of the JEC finding.
The Appellate Review Committee
On July 12, 1990, The Chicago Bar Association’s Board of Managers adopted procedures establishing a separate Appellate Review Committee to act independently from the Judicial Evaluation Committee (JEC).
The new Appellate Review Committee was recommended by a special committee appointed by past president Chester L. Blair. Made up of 30 lawyers, the committee hears appeals only from candidates who receive a “Not Recommended” rating from the JEC.
The candidate may request a re-evaluation by the appellate committee only on the basis that he or she believes that errors or omissions were made in the original screening process.
The Resolution adopted by the CBA’s Board of Managers provides that: A re-evaluation shall only be ordered on a determination that the Judicial Evaluation Committee’s Hearing Division’s finding was clearly erroneous. A reevaluation shall not be ordered solely because the Appellate Review Panel disagrees with the Judicial Evaluation Committee’s findings.
The Appellate Review Committee’s authority will be limited to directing that the candidate be given a new hearing by the JEC or denying the appeal.
Prior to the formation of the new Appellate Review Committee, all appeals were handled within the JEC. These new appellate procedures only apply to candidates evaluated by the JEC after July 12, 1990.
Reporting of Findings
The CBA has always reported its JEC findings to the public for all elective judicial positions.
On February 19, 1987, The CBA Board of Managers amended the JEC governing resolution to provide publication of “Statements of Reasons” for all such elective positions and specified appointive positions, such as associate judgeships.
CHICAGO BAR ASSOCIATION JUDICIAL EVALUATION COMMITTEE FINDINGS
FOR NOVEMBER 6, 2012 JUDICIAL RETENTION ELECTION
The Chicago Bar Association’s Judicial Evaluation Committee completed its evaluation process for retention candidates on September 18, 2012. Candidates participating in the JEC screening process receive a finding of “Qualified” or “Not Recommended.” Of the 58 judges on the ballot, The JEC found one Illinois Appellate Court Justice “Qualified,” and 51 Circuit Court judges “Qualified” to be retained by Cook County voters. Seven Circuit Court Judges were found “Not Recommended” for retention. The results for retention candidate evaluations and findings are as follows:
ILLINOIS APPELLATE COURT
QUALIFIED
James Fitzgerald Smith
CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY
QUALIFIED
Martin S. Agran Joyce Marie Murphy Gorman Patricia Banks Catherine Marie Haberkorn Ronald F. Bartkowicz Orville E. Hambright Carole Kamin Bellows Garritt E. Howard Maura SlatteryBoyle Carol M. Howard Daniel Patrick Brennan Michael J. Howlett, Jr. Mary MargaretBrosnahan Moshe Jacobius Robert Lopez Cepero Paul A. Karkula Matthew E. Coghlan Joseph G. Kazmierski, Jr. Maureen Elizabeth Connors* Stuart F. Lubin Grace G. Dickler Marvin P. Luckman Christopher Donnelly Marcia Maras Kathy M. Flanagan Jill C. Marisie Ellen L. Flannigan James Michael McGing Peter Flynn Mike McHale Raymond Funderburk James PatrickMurphy Thomas W. Murphy Marya Nega P. Scott Neville, Jr. * Joan MargaretO’Brien Patrick W. “Pat” O’Brien Ramon Ocasio III Stuart E. Palmer* Lee Preston Mary Colleen Roberts Thomas David Roti Drella C. Savage Colleen F. Sheehan Diane M. Shelley James M. Varga Carl Anthony Walker Richard F. Walsh Camille E. Willis E. Kenneth Wright, Jr.
CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY
NOT RECOMMENDED
Cynthia Brim Rodney Hughes Brooks Gloria Chevere Loretta Eadie-Daniels James D. Egan Pamela E. Hill-Veal Lisa Ruble Murphy
*Assigned to Appellate
FINDINGS FOR COOK COUNTY JUDGES SEEKING RETENTION FOR JUSTICE OF THE ILLINOIS APPELLATE COURT
JAMES FITZGERALD SMITH QUALIFIED
Judge James Fitzgerald Smith is “Qualified” for retention as a Justice of the Illinois Appellate Court. Justice Fitzgerald was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1975 and has served as a judge since 1989. Justice Fitzgerald was elected to the Illinois Appellate Court in 2002 and has great passion for his assignment. Justice Fitzgerald is diligent and well regarded for his integrity and legal knowledge.
MARTIN S. AGRAN QUALIFIED
Judge Martin Agran is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Agran was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1972 and has served as a judge since 1994. Judge Agran is an experienced judge and has served in the Circuit Court’s Civil, Criminal and Juvenile Justice Divisions. Judge Agran is currently assigned to the Third Municipal District in Rolling Meadows. Judge Agran is well regarded for his knowledge of the law, judicial experience, diligence, compassion, and outstanding demeanor.
PATRICIA BANKS QUALIFIED
Judge Patricia Banks is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Banks was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1973 and was elected a Circuit Court Judge in 1994. Judge Banks receives high marks by lawyers who appear before her in the Law Division. In 2010, Chief Judge Timothy C. Evans selected Judge Banks to organize the Circuit Court’s new Elder Law and Miscellaneous Remedies Division. Judge Banks has provided outstanding leadership in organizing the new Division and is an asset to the Circuit Court.
RONALD F. BARTKOWICZ QUALIFIED
Judge Ronald F. Bartkowicz is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Bartkowicz was admitted to practice law in 1965 and was appointed an Associate Judge in 1985. Judge Bartkowicz was elected a Circuit Court Judge in 1994 and is currently assigned to the Law Division’s Individual Commercial Calendar Section. Judge Bartkowicz presides over a busy call with many complex legal matters. Judge Bartkowicz is hardworking, thoughtful, and well regarded for his fine demeanor and punctuality.
CAROLE KAMIN BELLOWS QUALIFIED
Judge Carol Kamin Bellows is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Bellows was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1960 and has served as a judge since 1986. Judge Bellows is assigned to the Domestic Relations Division and is well respected for her knowledge of the law and judicial ability. Judge Bellows is an asset to the bench.
MAURA SLATTERY BOYLE QUALIFIED
Judge Maura Slattery Boyle is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Boyle was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1993 and became a judge in 2000. Judge Boyle is conscientious, hardworking, and well respected for her knowledge of the law and dedication to the judiciary.
Judge Daniel Brennan is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Brennan was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1995 and has served as a judge since 2006. Judge Brennan is assigned to the Chancery Division and presides over a high-volume court. Judge Brennan is hardworking, diligent, articulate, and has outstanding judicial temperament.
CYNTHIA BRIM NOT RECOMMENDED
The candidate declined to participate in the Judicial Evaluation Committee (JEC) screening process and, therefore, according to The Chicago Bar Association’s governing resolution for the JEC, is automatically found NOT RECOMMENDED.
RODNEY HUGHES BROOKS NOT RECOMMENDED
Judge Rodney Hughes Brooks is “Not Recommended” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Brooks was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1980 and has served as a judge since 1994. Judge Brooks has a pleasant demeanor, but does not possess the requisite knowledge of the law and judicial ability to effectively manage a court call. Judge Brooks has made no attempt to improve his knowledge of the law and judicial ability and should not be retained.
MARY MARGARET BROSNAHAN QUALIFIED
Judge Mary M. Brosnahan is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Since becoming a judge in 2006, Judge Brosnahan has been assigned to a felony courtroom at Chicago’s Criminal Court. Judge Brosnahan is well respected for her knowledge of the law, diligence, and dedication to the justice system. Judge Brosnahan also volunteers in her community and is a frequent speaker at area schools about the Judicial Branch of government.
ROBERT LOPEZ CEPERO QUALIFIED
Judge Robert Lopez Cepero is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Lopez Cepero was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1984 and has served as a judge since 1994. Judge Lopez Cepero is currently assigned to the Law Division and is knowledgeable and empathetic. Judge Lopez Cepero is aware of concerns about his temperament and is taking steps to improve this important area of judicial competency
Judge Gloria Chevere is “Not Recommended” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Chevere was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1981. The candidate was elected in 2006 and is assigned to various First Municipal Felony courtrooms. Reports from attorneys describe the candidate as punctual with adequate legal knowledge and that she runs an efficient courtroom. Nevertheless, the candidate is found not recommended due to her unwillingness to conform to attendance policies established for all judges. This comes after she was the subject of a highly publicized news report about leaving her courtroom assignment early.
MATTHEW E. COGHLAN QUALIFIED
Judge Matthew E. Coghlan is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Coghlan was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1987 and has served as a judge since 2000. Judge Coghlan presides over a felony trial call at the Criminal Court. Judge Coghlan knows the law and is a hardworking, fair and compassionate judge.
MAUREEN ELIZABETH CONNORS QUALIFIED
Judge Maureen E. Connors is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Connors was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1979 and became an Associate Judge in 1988. In 1994, Judge Connors was elected to the Circuit Court and served in the Probate Division until 2010 when she was appointed to the Illinois Appellate Court. Judge Connors is hardworking and highly regarded for her knowledge of the law and excellent demeanor.
GRACE G. DICKLER QUALIFIED
Judge Grace G. Dickler is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Dickler was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1978 and was appointed an Associate Judge in 1988. Judge Dickler was elected to the Circuit Court in 2006 and currently serves as the Presiding Judge of the Domestic Relations Division. Judge Dickler has a zeal and dedication for the justice system. Judge Dickler is well regarded for her knowledge of the law, work ethic, and fairness.
CHRISTOPHER DONNELLY QUALIFIED
Judge Christopher J. Donnelly is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Donnelly was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1985 and has served as a judge since 1994. Judge Donnelly is currently assigned to the Sixth Municipal District. Judge Donnelly is experienced, dedicated, thoughtful, and well versed in both civil and criminal law. Judge Donnelly is diligent and compassionate about helping explain the law to the litigants who appear before him.
Judge Loretta Eadie-Daniels is “Not Recommended” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Eadie-Daniels was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1977 and served in the legal departments of the Chicago Transit Authority and the Chicago Housing Authority. In addition, Judge Eadie-Daniels served as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney from 1989-2000 before her election to the Circuit Court in 2000. Judge Eadie-Daniels is currently assigned to the Sixth Municipal District in Markham. Judge Eadie-Daniels’ “Not Recommended” finding is the result of continuing concerns about the judge’s temperament and knowledge of the law.
JAMES D. EGAN NOT RECOMMENDED
The candidate declined to participate in the Judicial Evaluation Committee (JEC) screening process and, therefore, according to The Chicago Bar Association’s governing resolution for the JEC, is automatically found NOT RECOMMENDED.
KATHY M. FLANAGAN QUALIFIED
Judge Kathy M. Flanagan is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Flanagan was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1979 and has served as a judge since 1988. Judge Flanagan served in the Domestic Relations Division until 1993 and is currently supervising judge of the Law Division’s motion call. Judge Flanagan runs an efficient courtroom and is respected by the lawyers who appear before her. Questions regarding Judge Flanagan’s temperament were raised by some lawyers and the judge is working to address these concerns.
ELLEN L. FLANNIGAN QUALIFIED
Judge Ellen L. Flannigan is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Flannigan was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1988 and has served as a judge since 2006. Judge Flannigan is currently assigned to the Domestic Violence Division and presides over a high-volume court. Judge Flannigan is hardworking, bright, articulate, and efficient in managing a difficult call.
PETER FLYNN QUALIFIED
Judge Peter Flynn is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Flynn was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1969 and was appointed to the Circuit Court in 1999. Judge Flynn has served in the Chancery Division for the past ten years and is highly regarded by the lawyers who appear before him for his knowledge of the law. Judge Flynn is diligent, thoughtful, and committed to the justice system.
RAYMOND FUNDERBURK QUALIFIED
Judge Raymond Funderburk is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Funderburk was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1979 and currently is assigned to a Jury Trial Court in the First Municipal Division. Judge Funderburk manages his call efficiently and is an experienced, diligent and hardworking judge.
JOYCE MARIE MURPHY GORMAN QUALIFIED
Judge Joyce M. Murphy Gorman is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Gorman was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1995 and has served as a judge since 2000. Judge Gorman is currently assigned to the First Municipal District and presides over a high-volume civil injury call. Judge Gorman knows the law and has a fine judicial demeanor and temperament.
CATHERINE MARIE HABERKORN QUALIFIED
Judge Catherine Haberkorn is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Haberkorn was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1981 and has served as a judge since 1995. Judge Haberkorn is currently assigned to the Criminal Division where she presides over a difficult call. Judge Haberkorn is a dedicated and compassionate judge.
ORVILLE E. HAMBRIGHT QUALIFIED
Judge Orville E. Hambright is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Hambright was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1977 and has served as a judge since 2005. Judge Hambright is currently assigned to the First Municipal Division and presides over one of the Forcible Entry and Detainer Courts. Judge Hambright presides over a high-volume courtroom and is a diligent and compassionate judge. Judge Hambright needs to become more efficient in managing a difficult call dominated by a majority of pro se litigants.
PAMELA E. HILL-VEAL NOT RECOMMENDED
The candidate declined to participate in the Judicial Evaluation Committee (JEC) screening process and, therefore, according to The Chicago Bar Association’s governing resolution for the JEC, is automatically found NOT RECOMMENDED.
Judge Garritt Howard is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Howard was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1982 and became a judge in 1994. Judge Howard is currently assigned to the Second Municipal Division where he presides over a felony criminal trial call. Judge Howard possesses an excellent temperament and is well regarded for his legal knowledge and ability. Judge Howard is an experienced and hardworking judge.
CAROL M. HOWARD QUALIFIED
Judge Carol Howard is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Howard was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1986 and has served as a judge since 2006. Judge Howard has a calm demeanor and is passionate about her service as a judge. However, concerns about Judge Howard’s legal ability and punctuality were raised and she should endeavor to improve in these areas.
MICHAEL J. HOWLETT, JR. QUALIFIED
Judge Michael J. Howlett, Jr. is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Howlett was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1973 and served as an Associate Judge from 1983-1986. Judge Howlett was appointed to the Circuit Court in 2005 and elected a Circuit Court Judge in 2006. Judge Howlett is highly respected for his knowledge of the law, extensive experience, and outstanding judicial temperament.
MOSHE JACOBIUS QUALIFIED
Judge Moshe Jacobius is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Jacobius was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1975 and has served as a judge since 1991. Judge Jacobius is an experienced jurist and served as Presiding Judge of the Domestic Relations Division, where he made many administrative improvements. Judge Jacobius is currently serving as Presiding Judge of the Chancery Division and is making needed improvements in the management and disposition of mortgage foreclosure cases. Judge Jacobius is well regarded for his knowledge of the law, judicial experience, integrity, and outstanding judicial temperament.
PAUL A. KARKULA QUALIFIED
Judge Paul A. Karkula is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Karkula was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1980 and was appointed to the bench in 1999 and elected to the Circuit Court in 2000. Judge Karkula is well respected for his knowledge of the law, diligence, and fine temperament. Judge Karkula is enthusiastic and dedicated to the justice system.
JOSEPH G. KAZMIERSKI, JR. QUALIFIED
Judge Joseph G. Kazmierski is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Kazmierski was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1973 and was appointed and subsequently elected a Circuit Court Judge in 1994. Judge Kazmierski is an experienced trial judge and is well respected for his sound judgment, outstanding judicial temperament, and compassion. Judge Kazmierski is currently a supervising judge in the Criminal Division and is also a member of the Court’s Executive and Technology Committees.
STUART F. LUBIN QUALIFIED
Judge Stuart Lubin is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Lubin was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1974 and was appointed to the bench in 1991 and elected in 1994. Since his appointment to the bench, Judge Lubin has been assigned to the Circuit Court’s Juvenile Justice and Child Protection Division. Judge Lubin is highly regarded for his knowledge of the law, diligence, dedication, and compassion. Judge Lubin is passionate about his assignment and is an asset to the bench.
MARVIN P. LUCKMAN QUALIFIED
Judge Marvin Luckman is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Luckman was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1963 and has served as a judge since 1992. Judge Luckman is currently assigned to the First Municipal District and is respectful of those who appear in his court. Judge Luckman is knowledgeable about the law and is well regarded for his efficiency and fairness.
MARCIA MARAS QUALIFIED
Judge Marcia Maras is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Maras was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1982 and was appointed a judge in 1999. Judge Maras was elected to the Circuit Court in 2000 and is assigned to the Law Division. Judge Maras is well respected for her knowledge of the law, preparation, patience, and work ethic.
JILL C. MARISIE QUALIFIED
Judge Jill C. Marisie is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Marisie was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1990 and has served as a judge since 2006. Judge Marisie is experienced in civil and criminal law, hardworking, and possesses a fine temperament.
JAMES MICHAEL MCGING QUALIFIED
Judge James M. McGing is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge McGing was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1986 and has served as a judge since 2006. Judge McGing is experienced, hardworking, well organized, and runs an efficient courtroom.
Judge Mike McHale is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge McHale was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1991 and has served as a judge since 2006. Judge McHale is currently assigned to the Criminal Court and is highly regarded by lawyers who have appeared before him for his knowledge of the law and judicial ability.
LISA RUBLE MURPHY NOT RECOMMENDED
Judge Lisa Ruble Murphy is “Not Recommended” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Murphy was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1984 and has served as a judge since 1994. Judge Murphy has been in the Domestic Relations Division since 1995. Judge Murphy has been an Individual Calendar Domestic Relations Judge since 1997. The judge is experienced and knowledgeable in the field of domestic relations. Concerns about diligence, work ethic, and considerable delays in issuing written decisions resulted in a “Not Recommended” finding.
JAMES PATRICK MURPHY QUALIFIED
Judge James Patrick Murphy is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Murphy was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1995. Judge Murphy has served as a judge since 2006 and is currently assigned to the Circuit Court’s Domestic Violence Division. Judge Murphy manages a difficult call and is well regarded for his knowledge of the law, work ethic, diligence, and compassion.
THOMAS W. MURPHY QUALIFIED
Judge Thomas W. Murphy is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Murphy was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1979 and has served as a judge since 2006. Judge Murphy is currently assigned to the Fifth Municipal District and is well regarded by the lawyers who appear before him for his work ethic, knowledge of the law, diligence, and commitment to the justice system.
MARYA NEGA QUALIFIED
Judge Marya Nega is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Nega was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1980. Judge Nega served as an attorney in the Water Reclamation Department for 14 years before assuming the bench in 1994. Judge Nega is assigned to the Domestic Relations Division and possesses all the requisite qualifications to continue serving as a judge.
P. SCOTT NEVILLE, JR. QUALIFIED
Justice P. Scott Neville, Jr. is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Justice Neville was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1974 and was appointed a Circuit Court Judge in 1999. In June of 2004, Justice Neville was assigned to the Illinois Appellate Court, First District. Justice Neville’s trial and appellate experience make him qualified for retention as a Circuit Court Judge.
JOAN MARGARET O’BRIEN QUALIFIED
Judge Joan M. O’Brien is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge O’Brien was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1983 and has served as a judge since 2000. Judge O’Brien is currently assigned to the Fifth Municipal District where she presides over a variety of calls. Judge O’Brien is well respected for her knowledge of the law and fine judicial temperament.
PATRICK W. “PAT” O’BRIEN QUALIFIED
Judge Patrick W. O’Brien is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge O’Brien was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1975 and has served as a judge since 2006. Judge O’Brien is currently assigned to the First Municipal District. Judge O’Brien had extensive criminal experience as a practitioner and has worked hard to learn new aspects of civil law. Judge O’Brien has a quiet demeanor and takes a humble approach to learning new judicial assignments.
RAMON OCASIO III QUALIFIED
Judge Ramon Ocasio III is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Ocasio was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1989 and has served as a judge since 2006. Judge Ocasio is currently assigned to the Fourth Municipal District and is well regarded for his fine demeanor, work ethic, and compassion.
STUART E. PALMER QUALIFEID
Justice Stuart Palmer is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Justice Palmer was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1979 and has served as a judge since 1994. In January 2012, Judge Palmer was assigned to the Illinois Appellate Court. Justice Palmer is highly regarded for his knowledge of civil and criminal law, judicial experience, work ethic, and excellent judicial demeanor. Justice Palmer teaches judges at judicial seminars and is actively involved as a member of several court committees.
LEE PRESTON QUALFIED
Judge Lee Preston is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Preston was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1978 and has served as a judge since 1994. Judge Preston is enthusiastic and passionate about the justice system and is well regarded for his integrity, knowledge of the law, and excellent demeanor.
Judge Mary Colleen Roberts is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Roberts was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1989 and has served as a judge since 2006. Judge Roberts serves as a floating judge in the Criminal Division. Judge Roberts is known for her pleasant demeanor, legal knowledge and ability, work ethic and impartiality.
THOMAS DAVID ROTI QUALIFIED
Judge Thomas D. Roti is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Roti was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1970 and served as General Counsel for a major corporation until he assumed the bench in 2000. Judge Roti served in the First Municipal District from 2000-2003 and is currently assigned to the Third Municipal District where he hears both civil and criminal matters. Judge Roti is well respected for his knowledge of the law and excellent demeanor.
DRELLA C. SAVAGE QUALIFIED
Judge Drella Savage is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Savage was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1984 and has served as a judge since 1994. Before her election to the bench, Judge Savage worked at a private law firm, clerked for Judge Manning, and served as an Administrative Law Judge. Judge Savage is currently assigned to the motion call in the Law Division, where she is well regarded for her knowledge of the law, diligence, and work ethic.
COLLEEN F. SHEEHAN QUALIFIED
Judge Colleen F. Sheehan is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Sheehan was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1988 and has served as a judge since 2000. Judge Sheehan is currently assigned to the Juvenile Justice Division and is well respected for her knowledge of the law and compassion. Judge Sheehan is actively involved in community outreach programs to help reduce youth violence.
DIANE M. SHELLEY QUALIFIED
Judge Diane M. Shelley is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Shelley was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1984 and has served as a judge since 2006. Judge Shelley is currently assigned to the First Municipal District and is compassionate about her assignment. Judge Shelley has made strides to improve her knowledge of the law and has received positive references from those who appear in her court.
Judge James M. Varga is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Varga was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1978 and has served as a judge since 1994. Judge Varga is an experienced and knowledgeable judge. However, lawyers who have appeared before Judge Varga have raised concerns about his attitude and judicial temperament. Judge Varga is aware of these concerns and is working to improve his judicial demeanor and temperament.
CARL ANTHONY WALKER QUALIFIED
Judge Carl Walker is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Walker was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1992 and has served as a judge since 2006. Judge Walker is currently serving in the Juvenile Justice Division and is an enthusiastic, passionate and hardworking judge. Judge Walker possesses an excellent temperament and is well versed in both civil and criminal Law. In addition to his judicial duties, Judge Walker teaches and is involved in charitable and legal organizations.
RICHARD F. WALSH QUALIFIED
Judge Richard F. Walsh is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Walsh was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1972 and has served as a judge since 1994. Judge Walsh is currently assigned to the Juvenile Justice and Child Protection Department. Judge Walsh is an experienced judge well regarded for his knowledge of the law and fine judicial temperament. Judge Walsh is committed to his assignment and cares greatly about the children who appear in his court.
CAMILLE E. WILLIS QUALIFIED
Judge Camille E. Willis is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Willis was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1984 and has served as a judge since 1994. Judge Willis is currently assigned to the Sixth Municipal District in Markham. Judge Willis has experience in both civil and criminal matters. Judge Willis is well regarded for her knowledge of civil and criminal law, fairness, diligence, and judicial experience.
E. KENNETH WRIGHT, JR. QUALIFIED
Judge E. Kenneth Wright, Jr. is “Qualified” for retention as a Circuit Court Judge. Judge Wright was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1977 and has served as a judge since 1994. Judge Wright serves as Presiding Judge of the First Municipal District and has supervisory authority for more than 110 judges sitting in numerous high-volume courts. Judge Wright is well liked and respected by his peers for his knowledge of the law, even temperament, calm demeanor, and exceptional administrative skills.
On September 25, 2012, The Chicago Bar Association released its findings for the two candidates running to fill the Fitzgerald vacancy on the Illinois Supreme Court in the November 6, 2012 general election. Of these candidates, one has been found “Highly Qualified,” and 1 has been found “Qualified.”
NOTE: THE FOLLOWING IS THE FULL TEXT OF STATEMENT OF REASONS FOR THE SUPREME COURT CANDIDATES.
MARY JANE THEIS (D) HIGHLY QUALIFIED
Justice Mary Jane Theis is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Justice of the Illinois Supreme Court. Justice Theis was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1974 and served as an Assistant Cook County Public Defender until her appointment to the Circuit Court of Cook County in 1983. Justice Theis served in the First Municipal Division from 1983-1987; in the Criminal Division from 1988-1992; and in the Chancery Division before her appointment and election to the Illinois Appellate Court in 1994. In 2010, Justice Theis was appointed to the Illinois Supreme Court. Justice Theis is highly respected for her legal knowledge and experience, outstanding temperament, and unquestioned integrity. Justice Theis is intelligent, thoughtful, and dedicated to the law and our justice system.
JAMES GERARD RILEY (R) QUALIFIED
Judge James G. Riley is “Qualified” for the office of Justice of the Illinois Supreme Court. Judge Riley was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1982 and was engaged in the private practice of law until his election to the Circuit Court in 1996. Judge Riley is assigned to the Probate Division and handles the disabled adult and decedent calls. Judge Riley is widely known for his integrity and strong work ethic. References praise him for his grasp of the intricacies of probate law and efficiently handling voluminous calls including the issuing of opinions.
On September 25, 2012, The Chicago Bar Association released its findings for the 6 candidates running to fill the Cahill, Coleman, Gallagher, O’Brien, Theis and Tully vacancies on the Illinois Appellate Court in the November 6, 2012 general election. The JEC has found 2 of those candidates Highly Qualified and 4 Qualified .
NOTE: THE FOLLOWING IS THE FULL TEXT OF STATEMENTS OF REASONS FOR EACH APPELLATE COURT CANDIDATE.
MATHIAS WILLIAM DELORT (D) HIGHLY QUALIFIED
Judge Mathias William Delort is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Justice of the Illinois Appellate Court. Judge Delort was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1985 and concentrated his practice in local government, education, election law, and appellate practice. Judge Delort became an Associate Judge in 2007 and is currently assigned to the Mortgage Foreclosure/Mechanics Lien Section in the Chancery Division. Judge Delort is well regarded for his knowledge of the law, work ethic, and organizational and writing skills.
FOR JUDGE OF THE ILLINOIS APPELLATE COURT (Coleman)
NATHANIEL ROOSEVELT HOWSE, JR.(D) HIGHLY QUALIFIED
Justice Nathaniel R. Howse, Jr. is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Justice of the Illinois Appellate Court. Justice Howse was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1976 and had an extensive trial practice before becoming a judge in 1998. Judge Howse was retained for an additional six-year term in 2004 and was appointed to the Illinois Appellate Court in 2009. Justice Howse is well respected for his knowledge of the law, work ethic, well-written opinions, and outstanding demeanor.
FOR JUDGE OF THE ILLINOIS APPELLATE COURT (Gallagher)
P. SCOTT NEVILLE, JR. (D) QUALIFIED
Justice P. Scott Neville, Jr. is “Qualified” for the office of Justice of the Illinois Appellate Court. Justice Neville was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1974 and was appointed a Circuit Court Judge in 1999. In June of 2004, Justice Neville was assigned to the Illinois Appellate Court, First District. Justice Neville’s trial and appellate experience make him qualified for the Appellate Court.
FOR JUDGE OF THE ILLINOIS APPELLATE COURT (O’Brien)
JESSE G. REYES (D) QUALIFIED
Judge Jesse G. Reyes is “Qualified” for the office of Justice of the Illinois Appellate Court. Judge Reyes was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1984 and became a judge in 1997. Judge Reyes is currently assigned to the Chancery Division’s Mortgage Foreclosure and Mechanics Lien Division. Judge Reyes is very involved in community, philanthropic and professional activities. Judge Reyes possesses the legal knowledge and ability to serve as an Appellate Court Justice.
MAUREEN ELIZABETH CONNORS (D) QUALIFIED
Judge Maureen E. Connors is “Qualified” for the office of Justice of the Illinois Appellate Court. Judge Connors was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1979 and became an Associate Judge in 1988. In 1994, Judge Connors was elected to the Circuit Court and served in the Probate Division until 2010 when she was appointed to the Illinois Appellate Court. Judge Connors has served as an Appellate Court Justice for the past ten months. Judge Connors has established an excellent reputation on the Appellate Court and is highly regarded her knowledge of the law, excellent demeanor, and well-written opinions.
FOR JUDGE OF THE ILLINOIS APPELLATE COURT (Tully)
TERRENCE J. LAVIN (D) QUALIFIED
Justice Terrence J. Lavin is “Qualified” for the office of Justice of the Illinois Appellate Court. Justice Lavin was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1983 and was appointed to the Illinois Appellate Court in 2010. Before his appointment to the Illinois Appellate Court, Justice Lavin had an extensive trial practice concentrating in torts and medical malpractice. Justice Lavin is highly regarded for his knowledge of civil law and has published numerous articles about Civil Trial Practice. Justice Lavin serves as the Presiding Judge of the Fourth Appellate Division and is well regarded for his knowledge of the law, legal scholarship, writing skills, and strong work ethic.
FOR COOK COUNTY CIRCUIT COURT AND SUBCIRCUIT COURT VACANCIES
On September 25, 2012, The Chicago Bar Association released the results of independent screenings for the 37 judicial candidates seeking Cook County Circuit Court positions in the November 6, 2012 general election.
Of the 37 candidates seeking election for Circuit Court positions, 34 were screened by the Judicial Evaluation Committee of the CBA. The JEC has found 8 of those candidates Highly Qualified, 20 Qualified and 9 Not Recommended. The 3 candidates who declined to participate in the JEC screening process, were found automatically “Not Recommended” according to JEC governing bylaws.
NOTE: THE FOLLOWING IS THE FULL TEXT OF STATEMENTS OF REASONS FOR EACH CIRCUIT AND SUBCIRCUIT COURT CANDIDATE.FINDINGS FOR COOK COUNTY CIRCUIT COURT VACANCIES KAREN LYNN O’MALLEY (D) QUALIFIED
Karen Lynn O’Malley is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. O’Malley was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1992 and served as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney for 17 years before entering private practice. Ms. O’Malley concentrates her practice in personal injury, medical malpractice, construction, and negligence matters. Ms. O’Malley has taught trial advocacy and is active in bar association and community work. Ms. O’Malley is well regarded for her knowledge of the law, legal ability, and outstanding demeanor.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Jordan)
JEAN PRENDERGAST ROONEY (D) HIGHLY QUALIFIED
Judge Jean Prendergast Rooney is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Judge Prendergast Rooney was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1994 and was appointed to the Circuit Court in 2010. Prior to her appointment to the Circuit Court, Judge Prendergast served as a law clerk in the Illinois Appellate Court, the Illinois Supreme Court, and in private practice. Judge Prendergast Rooney is hardworking and well respected for her knowledge of the law and fine judicial demeanor and temperament.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Kinnaird)
ERICA L. REDDICK (D) QUALIFIED
Judge Erica Reddick is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Judge Reddick was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1991 and was appointed a Circuit Court Judge in 2010. Prior to becoming a judge, she served as an Assistant Cook County Public Defender. Judge Reddick is well regarded for her work ethic and integrity.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Moran)
RUSSELL W. HARTIGAN (D) HIGHLY QUALIFIED
Judge Russell W. Hartigan is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Judge Hartigan was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1976 and had an extensive litigation practice before becoming a judge in 2010. Judge Hartigan currently is assigned to a misdemeanor court in the First Municipal District. Judge Hartigan is well respected for his knowledge of the law and outstanding demeanor and temperament.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (O’Brien, Jr.)
CYNTHIA RAMIREZ (D) QUALIFIED
Cynthia Ramirez is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Ramirez was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1990 and has served in both the government and private sectors. Since 2000, Ms. Ramirez has served as an Administrative Law Judge for the Illinois Department of Public Health. Ms. Ramirez has a fine demeanor and possesses the requisite legal knowledge and experience to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Frossard)
DIANN KAREN MARSALEK (D) QUALIFIED
Diann K. Marsalek is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Marsalek was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1990 and currently serves as a Legal Advisor in the Administrative Hearings Department of the Illinois Secretary of State’s Office. Ms. Marsalek has extensive legal and trial experience and has a soft-spoken demeanor. Ms. Marsalek possesses all the requisite qualifications to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Pucinski)
LORNA ELLEN PROPES (D) HIGHLY QUALIFIED
Lorna Ellen Propes is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Propes was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1975 and has a wealth of practice and trial experience in both civil and criminal law. Ms. Propes enjoys an excellent reputation in the legal community and possesses outstanding credentials for judicial service.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Simmons, Jr.)
JESSICA A. O’BRIEN (D) QUALIFIED
Jessica O’Brien is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. O’Brien was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1998 and is serving as a litigation attorney in the Income Tax Section of the Illinois Department of Revenue. Ms. O’Brien has an LLM degree in Taxation and Employee Benefits. In addition, Ms. O’Brien has served as the General Counsel for the Illinois Lottery since 2011. Ms. O’Brien possesses the breadth of legal knowledge and experience to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Stewart)
PAMELA M. LEEMING (D) QUALIFIED
Judge Pamela Leeming is “Qualified” to serve as a Recalled Judge of the Circuit Court. Judge Leeming was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1990 and served as an Assistant Cook County Public Defender for twenty years before her appointment to the bench in 2009. Judge Leeming’s extensive knowledge and experience in Criminal Law has served her well on the bench. Judge Leeming is well respected for her integrity and excellent judicial demeanor. Judge Leeming is hardworking, conscientious, and enthusiastic about her role on the bench.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Stralka)
MICHAEL TULLY MULLEN (D) HIGHLY QUALIFIED
Michael T. Mullen is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Mullen was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1981 and served as an Assistant Illinois Attorney General and as an As sistant United States Attorney, rising to the position of deputy chief of the criminal division in which he supervised 35 attorneys. Mr. Mullen has received prestigious achievement awards from the U.S. Department of Justice. For the last 13 years, he has concentrated his practice in plaintiff’s personal injury work. Mr. Mullen has extensive civil and criminal practice experience and is highly regarded for his legal knowledge and ability and outstanding demeanor. Mr. Mullen is committed to public service and also serves as a suburban trustee.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Ward)
ELIZABETH MARY HAYES (D) NOT RECOMMENDED
Elizabeth Mary Hayes is “Not Recommended” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Hayes was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1986 and is currently serving as an Assistant Cook County Public Defender in the First Municipal District. At this stage of her career, Ms. Hayes does not possess the requisite knowledge of the law, temperament, demeanor, and practice experience to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Subcircuit 2 – Stuttley)
CARL B. BOYD (D) NOT RECOMMENDED
Carl B. Boyd is “Not Recommended” for the office of Associate Judge. Mr. Boyd was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1991 and has experience in a wide range of civil and criminal matters. Mr. Boyd possesses a fine demeanor and temperament. However, the candidate currently lacks sufficient practice and trial experience to serve as an Associate Judge.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Subcircuit 3 – McGann)
MAUREEN LEAHY DELEHANTY (D) QUALIFIED
Judge Maureen Delehanty is “Qualified” to serve as a Recalled Judge of the Circuit Court. Judge Delehanty was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1992 and was appointed a Circuit Court Judge in 2009. Judge Delehanty is dedicated to her assignment and receives high marks from attorneys who appear in her court.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Subcircuit 3 – Moore)
DANIEL R. DEGNAN (D) NOT RECOMMENDED*
The candidate declined to participate in the Judicial Evaluation Committee (JEC) screening process and, therefore, according to The Chicago Bar Association’s governing resolution for the JEC, is automatically found NOT RECOMMENDED.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Subcircuit 4 – Riley)
TERRY GALLAGHER (D) QUALIFIED
Terry Gallagher is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Gallagher was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1988 and served in the U.S. Navy’s Judge Advocate General’s Corps. Mr. Gallagher is currently engaged in private practice concentrating in civil litigation and criminal defense work. Mr. Gallagher has extensive trial experience and is well regarded for his work ethic and fine temperament.
Harry J. Fournier is “Not Recommended” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Fournier was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1997 and is currently a solo practitioner concentrating in Probate, Real Estate and Corporate Law. Mr. Fournier has transactional experience and is well regarded for his fine temperament and integrity. However, at this stage of his career, he does not possess the requisite depth and breadth of practice experience to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Subcircuit 4A)
EDWARD M. MALONEY (D) QUALIFIED
Edward M. Maloney is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Maloney was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1978 and concentrates his practice in Criminal Law, DUI and Administrative Hearings. Mr. Maloney has a broad base of legal experience and has been a member of several Illinois Task Forces on driving safety. Mr. Maloney is highly regarded by his peers and possesses all the requisite qualifications to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.
CHRISTINE COOK (R) QUALIFIED
Christine Cook is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Cook was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1990 and has served as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney for 21 years. Ms. Cook has handled complex trial and appellate matters. Ms. Cook is highly regarded by her peers for her integrity, diligence, legal knowledge and ability.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Subcircuit 6 – Delgado)
BEATRIZ SANTIAGO (D) NOT RECOMMENDED
Beatriz Santiago is “Not Recommended” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms Santiago was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1996 and is currently serving as an Assistant Cook County Public Defender. Ms. Santiago has served in the Felony and Juvenile Justice Courts. While Ms. Santiago has court and trial experience, additional practice experience would enhance her knowledge of the law and ability to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.
AICHA MARIE MacCARTHY (D) NOT RECOMMENDED
Ms. Aicha Marie MacCarthy is “Not Recommended” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. MacCarthy was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1997 and has held a variety of positions including: service as a Hearing Officer for the Chicago Housing Authority and Traffic Prosecutor for the City of Chicago from 1998-2001 and as an Assistant Commissioner for the City of Chicago from 2001-2008. Ms. MacCarthy has been self-employed from 2009 to the present. Ms. MacCarthy has a fine demeanor and presented well. However, Ms. MacCarthy lacks substantive legal experience in complex matters and has limited practice experience. In addition, Ms. MacCarthy has not had any jury trial or appellate experience. At this stage of her career, Ms. MacCarthy does not possess the requisite depth and breadth of legal experience to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Subcircuit 7 – Starks)
TOMMY BREWER (D) QUALIFIED
Tommy H. Brewer is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Brewer was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1976. Mr. Brewer has a wide range of experience which includes employment in the Massachusetts Attorney General’s office for four years, service as an FBI agent, service as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney, and, as an Administrative Law Judge in the Illinois Department of Professional Regulation. Prior to his appointment, Mr. Brewer had been a sole practitioner concentrating his practice in criminal defense. He possesses the requisite qualities to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Subcircuit 7 – Terrell)
WILLIAM G. GAMBONEY (D) HIGHLY QUALIFIED
William Gamboney is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Gamboney was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1977 and served as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney for fifteen years. Following his service in the State’s Attorney’s office, Mr. Gamboney entered private practice and has concentrated in criminal defense work. Mr. Gamboney has tried many complex cases and is highly respected for his integrity, legal knowledge, trial skills, and outstanding demeanor.
KIMBERLY D. LEWIS (D) NOT RECOMMENDED*
The candidate declined to participate in the Judicial Evaluation Committee (JEC) screening process and, therefore, according to The Chicago Bar Association’s governing resolution for the JEC, is automatically found NOT RECOMMENDED.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Subcircuit 8 – Chiola)
CELIA LOUISE GAMRATH (D) HIGHLY QUALIFIED
Judge Celia Gamrath is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Judge Gamrath was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1994 and concentrated her practice in family law before her appointment to the bench in 2010. Judge Gamrath treats lawyers and litigants with respect and receives high marks for her knowledge of the law, fine temperament, and efficiency in managing her courtroom. Judge Gamrath has participated in teaching family law to other judges and was appointed as a Peer Review Editor for the Family Law Benchbook.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Subcircuit 8 – Cole)
JOHN H. EHRLICH (D) HIGHLY QUALIFIED
John H. Ehrlich is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Ehrlich was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1988 and is currently serving as Deputy Corporation Counsel, Torts Division, in the City of Chicago’s Law Department. Mr. Ehrlich supervises a large staff and is well respected by his peers for his legal knowledge and ability.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Subcircuit 8 – Roy)
DEBORAH JEAN GUBIN (D) QUALIFIED
Judge Deborah Jean Gubin is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Judge Gubin was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1975 and was appointed a Circuit Court Judge in 2010. Judge Gubin is currently assigned to the First Municipal District and is managing a high-volume call in Traffic Court. Judge Gubin knows the law and has addressed concerns regarding her temperament. Judge Gubin is qualified to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.
LAURA LIU (D) QUALIFIED
Laura Cha-Yu Liu is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Liu was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1991 and has had diverse civil practice experience concentrating in Municipal and Health Care Law. Ms. Liu is thoughtful, organized, and well regarded for her work ethic. Ms. Liu possesses the requisite qualifications for service as a Circuit Court Judge.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Subcircuit 9 – Bender)
LIONEL JEAN-BAPTISTE (D) QUALIFIED
Lionel Jean-Baptiste is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Jean-Baptiste was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1991. Mr. Jean-Baptiste is engaged in the private practice of law and concentrates his practice in transactional litigation, real estate, immigration, and contract matters. Mr. Jean-Baptiste currently serves as an Alderman in Evanston and is active in community work. Mr. Jean-Baptiste is well regarded for his integrity and work ethic.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Subcircuit 9 -Epstein)
LARRY G. AXELROOD (D) HIGHLY QUALIFIED
Judge Larry Axelrood is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Judge Axelrood was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1985 and served as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney and in private practice concentrating in criminal defense before his appointment to the bench in 2005. Judge Axelrood possesses an outstanding demeanor and temperament and is highly regarded for his knowledge of the law and ability. Judge Axelrood presides over the new Veterans Court and Mental Health Court calls and treats all litigants with respect.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Subcircuit 10 – Locallo)
THOMAS R. ALLEN (D) QUALIFIED
Judge Thomas R. Allen is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Judge Allen was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1977. Judge Allen had extensive legal experience in both the government and private sectors before his appointment to the bench in December 2010. In addition, Judge Allen served as an Alderman for the City of Chicago for 18 years. Judge Allen is well respected for his strong work ethic, integrity, and knowledge of the law.
MICHAEL R. CLANCY (D) QUALIFIED
Michael R. Clancy is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Clancy was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1989. Mr. Clancy is engaged in the private practice of law concentrating in criminal defense matters. Mr. Clancy is thoughtful, articulate, and well regarded for his legal knowledge and ability.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Subcircuit 11 – Urso)
LISA ANN MARINO (D) QUALIFIED
Lisa A. Marino is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Marino was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1988 and is currently engaged in private practice concentrating in real estate tax, commercial and residential real estate law, and zoning matters. Ms. Marino is highly regarded for her knowledge of real estate tax law and has general litigation experience. Ms. Marino has a fine demeanor and possesses all the requisite qualifications to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Subcircuit 12 – Rochford)
ANDREA M. SCHLEIFER (D) QUALIFIED
Andrea M. Schleifer is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Schleifer was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1979 and is well versed in both civil and criminal law. Ms. Schleifer concentrates her practice in domestic relations and has handled many complex cases. Ms. Schleifer is well spoken, even tempered, and possesses all the necessary qualifications for service as a Circuit Court Judge.
JAMES PAUL PIECZONKA (R) NOT RECOMMENDED
James Pieczonka is “Not Recommended” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Pieczonka was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1983 and is currently a solo practitioner concentrating in Taxation, Real Estate and Condominium Law. Mr. Pieczonka’s practice and court experience is limited. Mr. Pieczonka held a real estate broker’s license from 2004-2007 and was actively involved as a broker during this period. The candidate owns a number of properties that are currently in foreclosure and is personally involved in several residual court actions. Mr. Pieczonka needs to gain additional practice experience and resolve these financial responsibility concerns before reapplying to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.
PAUL S. PAVLUS (R) QUALIFIED
Paul S. Pavlus is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Pavlus was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1993 and has served as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney for 18 years. Mr. Pavlus is currently a supervisor in the Domestic Violence Unit. Mr. Pavlus is well respected for his work ethic, integrity, compassion, and dedication to the law.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Subcircuit 13 A)
MARTIN C. KELLEY (R) NOT RECOMMENDED*
The candidate declined to participate in the Judicial Evaluation Committee (JEC) screening process and, therefore, according to The Chicago Bar Association’s governing resolution for the JEC, is automatically found NOT RECOMMENDED.
FOR JUDGE OF THE CIRCUIT COURT OF COOK COUNTY (Subcircuit 14 – O’Gara)
REGINA ANN SCANNICCHIO (D) QUALIFIED
Judge Regina Ann Scannicchio is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Judge Scannicchio was admitted to practice law in 1989 and practiced family law before her appointment to the bench in 2011. Judge Scannicchio is currently assigned to Traffic Court in the First Municipal District. Judge Scannicchio is highly regarded for her knowledge of the law and dedication to the justice system. Judge Scannicchio is active in the bar and is a frequent speaker at continuing legal education seminars.
Provided As A Public Service Of The Chicago Bar Association 321 S. Plymouth Court Chicago, IL 60604 312-554-2000 Paid for by The Chicago Bar Association 2012 Judicial Evaluation Fund. A copy of the CBA Report is on file with the State Board of Elections.
